JAN STEELE’S JAWBREAKER: MEMOIR OF A WOMEN’S SHELTER

In the mid-1970s, Jan Steele worked on the front lines as a counsellor at the Calgary Women’s Emergency Shelter. Jawbreaker: Memoir of a Women’s Shelter is her account of the two and a half years she spent opening the door to women and children facing homelessness due to domestic violence, poverty, and mental illness. In the 70s, the idea that a woman could leave her abusive husband was novel, and the shelter was just getting started. The shelter was located in a three-storey Victorian home that in its heyday would have been quite fancy, but by the time Jan showed up it had become a fire hazard. At times all that stood between a belligerent abuser and his wife was a broken deadbolt that required a screwdriver to operate and the highest security was a baseball bat. Jan was optimistic about her ability to help in the shelter but she quickly transformed from a positive, fresh-faced newcomer to a seasoned regular struggling with balancing the needs of the women and the dysfunctional management.

Jawbreaker is based on a diary that Jan wrote during her time at the shelter. It reflects her self-described immaturity and depicts an incredibly blunt and heartbreaking portrait of domestic violence. Jan portrays herself as she was when she was at the shelter, and has not adapted her perspective or judgements, so at times they seem harsh or juvenile. Nothing is sugar coated, and everything is outrageously unfair. One client emigrated to Canada with her husband who was abusive and to punish her, he threw boiling oil at her face. She spent many weeks at the shelter with her head wrapped entirely in bandages before Jan ever sees the depth of the abuse she suffered. The book is a litany of similar stories. One woman seeks refuge with her four boys, but they are kidnapped by their father, and it ends with the police luring the man to the shelter, coaxing the children back, and then they serve him a ticket for illegal possession of firearms. But some stories are not so clear cut, perhaps the most troubling is that of a woman who left her dog when she fled her home. When she retuned, her husband told her he had shot the dog. She was heart broken, but then later, he told her he set the dog free. She desperately searched, but then, he told her again, the dog was dead, and on and on, the woman never learned the truth. Successes are few and fleeting, humour is scarce.

Domestic violence is still a prevalent problem, and while legal and social reforms have occurred since 1970, the assistance available to women is insufficient. The shelter could have 100 women and children a month, but more than often they had to turn women away. Resources were sparing, and the shelter could always use more of everything, and management constantly got in the way of the front-line workers, an all-too familiar story for anyone on the front lines today. Additionally, from the women Jan speaks of, it’s clear that domestic violence doesn’t affect any specific demographic, but is indiscriminate, pervading culture, class and race.

This book is startling, exhausting and frustrating, but at its core, it pays respect to the women who passed through the shelter doors, and honours the experiences of women who are victims of domestic violence. Readers interested or involved in social work, psychology and counselling will find value in the stories represented in the memoir. Jan deliberately maintains the language she used in her initial documentation that may have been common in 1970, but now feels dated and inappropriate. Some readers may find this book upsetting, as it does directly portray domestic violence and episodes of crisis, and suicide.

 

–Karyn Haag

JAN STEELE’S JAWBREAKER: MEMOIR OF A WOMEN’S SHELTER

CYNTHIA D’APRIX SWEENEY’S THE NEST

The four adult children in the Plumb family are set to receive a generous amount of money — referred to affectionately as “the Nest” by the Plumbs — from a trust set up by their late father. Intended to be a modest fund, thanks to an influential boost from the stock market, the money now represents enough, once divided among the four siblings, to solve all their significant financial problems. Living as if this windfall is a sure thing, the four Plumb children have been gambling in favour of debt all the while waiting for when they will receive the payout on the 40th birthday of Melody, the youngest.

 

Melody and her husband have been supporting their twin daughters who are now looking forward to college. Melody has been insisting upon living outside of their means all while keeping up appearances. Beatrice is struggling to write her second novel, after having to payback her advance. Jack keeps feeding money borrowed from his partner to his ever growing debt in an attempt to keep his business afloat. Yet, the security the Plumbs have felt from their expected Nest, which bolstered their irresponsible and unwise financial decisions, is challenged when the oldest brother, Leo, high on martinis and cocaine speeds away from a wedding reception. Leo’s crashes the car while a 19-year-old waitress performs a complicated sex act on him. The waitress loses a foot in the accident, while Leo loses his wife and the majority of his property and savings to the divorce before he heads to rehab. Paying the waitress to keep quiet (while herself avoiding the deportation of her parents) depletes the Nest within a year of the expected payout.

 

The Nest accurately and cleverly represents the greed and suffering that is brought about by the expectation for a lavish existence. The tension created by such a family dynamic is cleverly crafted by Sweeney’s choice to represent the narratives of all those affected by the Nest. There is a collection of secondary characters who add to the turmoil and strife that the Plumbs face as they attempt to hold Leo accountable to pay back what they believe to be owed. Sweeney explores grief as a retired fire-fighter struggles with losing his wife in the 9/11 attacks as he works each day digging through the rubble hoping to find something of hers. A black bi-sexual teenage girl represents a steady self-assurance while perhaps most obviously, a publisher who works quietly and diligently to build her life settles into a comfort that is a stark contrast to the deception, unease and failure of the Plumb siblings.

 

Sweeney’s representation of addiction isn’t as fully developed in Leo as it could be, but she does well with the depiction of what it is like to live with a disabled body, or to live as a single woman, or as a gay man. As she crafts the web of characters who are ultimately more connected than is apparent she depicts a wide reach of experience and perspective that keeps the anxiety of the Plumb’s situation from overwhelming the novel. This is a great read for anyone grappling with family dysfunction, while the will he/won’t he of Leo’s choices will keep the reader intrigued through the end.

 

–Karyn Haag

CYNTHIA D’APRIX SWEENEY’S THE NEST

GABBY RIVERA’S JULIET TAKES A BREATH

The first book to change the life of Juliet Palante is a feminist manifesto written by a white, hippy, lesbian, author Harlowe Brisbane. The book, Raging Flower, is all about taking pride in womanhood. For Juliet, this book represents a challenge to the heteronormative patriarchy that she has accepted as the normthrough her upbringing as a chubby, Puerto Rican, queer girl from the Bronx. “The first step in gaining [power] back is walking face first into the crashing seas and daring the patriarchy to follow.” This is the advice Juliet Palante wants to take to heart — after all her last name, Palante is Puerto Rican slang meaning “to move forward” or “a call out into the world for our people to keep it moving.”

Gabby Rivera writes Juliet Takes a Breath as a highly entertaining and informative take on the traditional bildungsroman. The plan is for Juliet to move to Portland, Oregon for the summer to intern for Harlowe, but first she has to say good bye to her first ever girlfriend, and come out to her family over dinner, which she assumes will go terribly, before she hops on a plane to what she expects is the safe, progressive arms of the Portland queer scene. Juliet is afraid, but open to the challenge of self-discovery and acceptance and excited to learn more about the subject of Harlowe’s teachings: radical feminism, women’s bodies, and how to actually be a politically aware queer kid.

In Juliet Takes a Breath, Rivera has expertly captures the distress and confusion that comes with working one’s way into an experienced and diverse community. Nothing in Portland is as Juliet expected. As soon as she lands she is quizzed on her identity (she doesn’t know how to answer), and challenged on not being queer enough. Through this immersion, Juliet solidifies her understanding and opinions on what it means for her to be queer, but also recognizes the challenges of occupying more than one identity. She learns enough to recognize racism, and classism in her deeply flawed heroes, and she learns to be open to change, and to things that are new and different.

In Juliet Takes A Breath Gabby Rivera writes openly and honestly about the value of intersectional feminism specifically in queer spaces. This book broadly represents the politics and sweeping changes in queer communities, and reflects the transition from rigid second-wave feminism to a practice more inclusive of diversity. There are a lot of lessons for Juliet, and for readers, as she learns to recognize white privilege and unintentional racism especially within feminist circles and how class and education affect social justice communities. The text of the book can be awkward and could have used a more detailed edit, however, the talent Rivera has for representing characters shines through.

Above all else though, Juliet Takes a Breath is about radical ways to love: self-love, family love, friendships, romantic love, and love in communities. Juliet remains rooted in her Puerto Rican family, but there is excitement for new loves and new perspectives, while, as she learns to negotiate each facet of her identity. This book is perfect for anyone who looks at a mainstream social movement with a critical eye, and any readers who hope to challenge their own understanding of where they stand in relation to their privilege and identity.

 

— Karyn Haag

GABBY RIVERA’S JULIET TAKES A BREATH

The Penguins Lessons by Tom Michell Book Review

In 1975, at the beginning of what would be a long period of political and economic unrest in Argentina, 23-year-old Tom Michell was to begin teaching at a boarding school in Argentina. Before he settled into life as a teacher he took a trip to Uruguay where he happened upon a group of Magellanic penguins who had been overwhelmed by an oil slick and washed ashore. He watched as each wave brought more and more lifeless penguins to rest on the rocks. Among them there was a lone survivor — an adult male Magellanic penguin who would be named Juan Salvado or Salvador (Saved or Savior) and who would live up to his name for all who met him. The Penguin Lessons by Tom Michell is a fantastic reflection on this period of Argentinian history, and how Michell’s life would come to be affected, and forever changed by Juan Salvado.

 

Bereft and rapt with the disaster spread before him Michell waded through the tide of corpses and devised a plan to assist the struggling penguin. He caught the bird and walked back to his lodging with the ten pound bird fighting against him with every step. With no thought for practicality and without the ability to Google “how to de-tar a penguin,” Michell set about cleaning the bird with the only materials at hand — dish soap, shampoo and a stick of butter. During this long and messy process, the bird transforms from a vicious enemy and realizes that Michell means him no harm. It’s with this transformation that Juan Salvado first shows his inquisitive personality as he sits calmly and encourages the cleansing.

 

The comical character and appearance of the Magellanic penguin lends itself well to the anthropomorphizing that humans are so eager to ascribe to the animals we adore. From the beginning Michell interpreted Juan Salvado’s inquisitive head tilt and imploring expression as questioning and often encouragement to continue his care. Juan Salvado refused all attempts to be returned to the sea, and so, concealed under a paper bag, and with little trouble Michell is successful in smuggling the large bird through Argentinian customs and back to the boarding school.

 

Through the book, Michell details the admiration of Juan Salvado. Michell kept the bird on his terrace, which piques the curiosity of a flock of students and administration. Once past the initial novelty of a penguin living at a boarding school, Juan Salvado ingratiated himself as the school rugby mascot. He also provided comfort and companionship among any struggling students. It is due to Juan Slavado’s charm that it is easy to forget at the time Argentina was a country of swift inflation changes and great political struggle. The economic situation permitted those with affluence to prosper while the poorest citizens suffered as their wages lost value overnight.

 

An especially touching anecdote is that of Juan Salvado’s influence on a student named Diego, characterized as a “diffident, shy thirteen-year-old lad, who gave the impression of being frightened by his own shadow.” Once Juan Salvado’s had his way with the boy — through an adventure in the school swimming pool — Diego is transformed into a school sports star and hero.
While the memoir reads as a comical and exotic take on an animal companionship tale, The Penguin Lessons is tempered by Michell’s careful detail in recalling the experience of living in such a turbulent and troubled nation.  It’s easy to focus on the well-being of Juan Salvado to drive the narrative, as Michell states early on: “I was hoping against hope that the penguin would survive because, as of that instant, he had a name, and with his name came the beginning of a bond that would last a lifetime.”

 

— Karyn Haag

The Penguins Lessons by Tom Michell Book Review

SUNIL YAPA’S YOUR HEART IS A MUSCLE THE SIZE OF A FIST

On November 30th, 1999, an estimated 40, 000 protesters gathered on the streets of Seattle in an attempt to shut down the World Trade Organization’s scheduled negotiations. The mass consisted of non-violent activists, anti-globalization organizations, labour unions, student groups, and a contingent of anarchists. Law enforcement was drastically ill prepared for the number of protestors and struggled to maintain order in the chaos. The situation quickly escalated into violence and brutality. Sunil Yapa bases the plot of Your Heart is a Muscle the Size of a Fist in the midst of the event and examines the details from the perspective of seven narrators, a homeless drifter, two non-violent protestors, three cops — including the Seattle police chief, and a Sri Lankan delegate set to attend the talks.

 

The novel builds on the premise that each narrator embodies the various ideological perspectives within the protests — each specifically crafted to illustrate a point about the complex nature of struggle. Yapa is deliberate and sometimes heavy-handed in his depiction of each individual, but creates multifaceted and complex characters who each exhibit empathy and vulnerability, as well as struggle and brutality. Victor, a teenage bi-racial runaway has been camping under a Seattle bridge after travelling around the world. He has no vested interest in the protests other than as a venue to sell weed. His estranged step-father, Police Chief Bishop, initially has simple and noble goals to maintain the safety of his streets. Non-violent protestor and medic King clashes with Park, a cop who responded to and was left disfigured by the Oklahoma City bombings while his partner Julia has been heavily influenced by her police involvement in the Rodney King riots.


Yapa’s tendency to overwrite dialogue, is tempered by his excellent portrayal of the rush brought on by activism. He narrates the feeling of a community bolstered by the emotional and unifying power of a chant. The majority of the novel is swamped in the uncomfortable claustrophobia of tear-gas and a social pressure to maintain status quo.  Protestors and police alike are on edge as they feel trapped into an increasingly violent and volatile situation. The strength of the novel rests on each character’s personal conflict between principled resolve and the thrill of rebellion.

 

Racial tensions and resulting police brutality play a key role and bring to mind the many stories of police brutality and the overbearing presence of racial-based violence that has been a catalyst for the Black Lives Matter movement and the protests in the United States. The text focuses so heavily on the moment-to-moment action in the protests to the almost complete exclusion of any discussion of the actual issues that sparked the protests. The interests of the WTO is represented solely by an additional narrator, Sri Lankan delegate Charles Wikramsinghe, who is mistaken by police to be involved in the protests. Though Wikramsinghe is as much an outsider among the protestors as he is an outsider representing the interests of a small country among the large industrial nations.
By setting the novel over the course of one day Yapa maintains a limited scope on an overwhelming situation, and the escalation of the violence and chaos of the protests propel the reader through the often breath-catching prose. Readers will enjoy the diversity of perspectives and the challenge of internal personal struggle.

 

— Karyn Haag

 

SUNIL YAPA’S YOUR HEART IS A MUSCLE THE SIZE OF A FIST

EILEEN MYLES’ CHELSEA GIRLS

“You can’t force a story that doesn’t want to be told,” writes Eileen Myles at the opening of the chapter “1969” in her recently republished novel Chelsea Girls.  The stories Myles doesn’t force seem to come all the same, and she has published twenty works, including three novels. The re-issue of Chelsea Girls accompanies the release of her collected poetry, I Must Be Living Twice which spans the prolific writer’s work from 1978 through 2012 and includes a section of new unpublished work.  The two publications pair well — Chelsea Girls providing the documentary background to Myles’ earlier work in the collected.

 

While much of Chelsea Girls reads as a contemporary coming of age novel, the New York that Myles experienced is that which could only occur in 1960-1970. She lives in a glamorous squalor — the kind of New York life that isn’t possible any more. Most of the stories in Chelsea Girls take place under a haze of drunkenness, but also there is an ever-present feeling of hunger. She writes of the friends who would buy her drinks and give her cigarettes, but she was too embarrassed to ask for food. In an interview published in Vulture she explains, “It helps that I was queer, it helps that I grew up working class,” she says. “I wasn’t afraid of being poor. I didn’t want to live in a big house. I’m the perfect size for poetry. I can move around.”

 

Both Myles poetry and her prose read as if she’s speaking the text aloud. In her novel, punctuation is indiscriminately placed, acting only as a pause, while her poems spill out in long streams of three or four word lines, seeming to hurry along. Also, the practice of savouring a poem, reading and re-reading it to pick up all the meaning carries well to Chelsea Girls, in which each chapter demands an individual consideration before applying it to the whole. There is no linear narrative, rather a series of stories that jump timelines and locations, but eventually portray a cohesive experience.  In interviews with Myles, she has explained that she wrote her first novel, Chelsea Girls as if she were writing down a film “I didn’t know how to write a novel, so I sort of let it happen in waves…the only way I could write it was to think like scenes in a movie.” she says “I was basically trying to put a voice track on a bunch of visual memories that couldn’t speak.”
The novel, much like her poetry, is a series of snapshots, vivid and brutal, depicting a difficult life of partying, addiction, abuse and coming of age mis-adventures. Myles’ character in Chelsea Girls is the working class Holden Caulfield. Trauma in the novel reads as a realization after the fact. In one chapter she depicts the sexual violence she experienced, but it reads full of doubt, so common place that it’s not really violence. She experiences the death of her alcoholic father when she is in 7th grade, and it solidifies in her the type of person she will be, “I would be a beatnik, I would make everyone so sad, and be so cool.” From this definitive beginning Chelsea Girls shows a constant defining, examining, and re-defining of what it means to the Eileen Myles — what a life looks like, what makes an individual within a family, what a female body looks and feels like, what it means to be queer, and where the lines are drawn.   

— Karyn Haag

EILEEN MYLES’ CHELSEA GIRLS

CARRIE BROWNSTEIN’S HUNGER MAKES ME A MODERN GIRL

The prologue to Carrie Brownstein’s memoir, Hunger Makes Me A Modern Girl, is set in 2006 and after a decade of touring with her band Sleater-Kinney she’s trying to decide how to best destroy everything she’s built — to get herself out. How hard will she have to slam her hand in a door? How much self-sabotage is enough to end the tour? “Sleater-Kinney was my family, the longest relationship I had ever been in; it held my secrets, my bones, it was in my veins, it had saved my life countless times; it still loved me even when I was terrible to it, it might have been the first unconditional love I’d ever known. And I was about to destroy Sleater-Kinney.”

 

The memoir is structured in three parts: Youth, Sleater-Kinney, and Aftermath. Brownstein says she set out to write a memoir with a clear narrative arc, and to reveal only what adds to the narrative. In Youth, Brownstein positions her self as a early music fan and unwitting comedian – using song lyrics in school projects, and singing Von-Trapp style renditions of her parents favourite songs to entertain their friends. Quickly, she becomes fascinated with musicians, and attends her first concerts chaperoned by her father. “To become a fan of something, to open and change, is a move of deliberate optimism, curiosity, and enthusiasm.” Fandom and the ability of music to sweep over all the turmoil of adolescence, allows Brownstein relief from her crumbling family life, and the abandonment she felt as the child of an anorexic and mostly absent mother, and a reserved closeted father.

 

“My story starts with me as a fan, and to be a fan is to know that loving trumps being beloved.” In her late teens, Brownstein writes, “I needed to press myself up against small stages, risking crushed toes, bruised sides, and the unpredictable undulation of the pit, just so I could get a glimpse of who I wanted to be.” Its at the front of small basement stages that she found the path to Olympia, Washinton’s scrappy Riot Grrrl scene, and met her Sleater-Kinney bandmate Corin Tucker.

 

It’s from this beginning, that informs the basis for who Brownstein wants to be, though it becomes evident that as Sleater-Kinney gains notoriety, Brownstein is never far from her awkward beginning. Maintaining her respect of fandom and negotiating her own discomfort at being put on a pedestal Brownstein writes, “how could I help if I was just like them? The disconnect between who I was on- and offstage would be so pronounced as to be jarring. Me, so small, so unqualified.” And yet, Hunger Makes Me a Modern Girl is a generous account of an awkward and isolated woman building a life and making her way though it.

 

Sleater-Kinney formed out of her relationship with Corin Tucker, after she moved to ‘90s music-mecca Olympia, WA. The middle of the memoir details the inception, recording process, and notes working with drummer Janet Weiss as the final solidification of Sleater-Kinney. Brownstein writes descriptively of the song writing and recording process, and notes the unique dynamic between her and her bandmates that forms the foundation of Sleater-Kinney. “My chords were half formed,” Brownstein writes, “I was always trying to leave room for Corin. My entire style of playing was built around somebody else playing guitar with me.” There is a chapter devoted to each album, and intermingling chapters outlining their rise from olympia, touring across the states and Europe, and opening for Pearl Jam. All the while the band had to negotiate their individual relationships with each other and to the band.

 

Brownstein writes confessionally with emotion and quite a bit of reflection and distance from the initial events of the Sleater-Kinney tours and her own emotional and physical turmoil. It’s abundantly clear that Brownstein wants to do right by her devoted fans, and reveals just enough to feel satisfying, without seeming invasive. She does well to position herself first and foremost as a fan herself, which allows her to tell her story from a humanizing perspective. She never exploits her position within the band to reveal unnecessary personal details about her bandmates, and she humbly offers herself up as an example of the fallible celebrity — in one passage she details how she sabotaged a meeting with Matador records executives who were interested in signing Sleater-Kinney.

 

Hunger takes notes from Sonic Youth’s Kim Gordon, who released her memoir Girl In a Band earlier this year, but Hunger reads less insular. Brownstein entirely omits her current work in Portlandia, but this work is not just for fans of Sleater-Kinney; it documents a sweeping look at the changes in fandom, recording, and the music industry in the past 20 years, citing influences from Kurt Cobain and Nirvana, and takes a look at the monolithic legend of Washington grunge from a perspective of both insider and outsider. Hunger starts with a brutal scene of sickness and desperation and it grows more compelling as plays out. It is ideal for readers who have felt on the outside, who have felt not quite right for the life they see before them.

 

–Karyn Haag

CARRIE BROWNSTEIN’S HUNGER MAKES ME A MODERN GIRL

Patti Smith’s M TRAIN

In an interview earlier this year, Patti Smith explained the title of her latest memoir, M Train, to mean “mind train” — an almost stream-of-consciousness trail of thoughts. Following the success of Just Kids, her 2010 memoir that received the National Book Award for Non-Fiction, this release meets the reader in present-day New York. Part travel journal, part meditation on the tremendous grief she’s felt in her life, and with a sharp focus on the spiritual weight of the objects around her, Smith narrates her observations through her incredible gift of memory.

About a third of the way through the work Smith writes, “Personally, I’m not much for symbolism. I never get it. Why can’t things just be as they are?” It’s at this point that the reader realizes the calm and measured precision in the words and phrases Smith uses to honour the ephemera of her life. She writes reverently of her father’s desk and chair, left to her when he passed away, and she notes that while it now rests in her brownstone, she has never dared to actually sit in the chair — an act that was forbidden in her childhood. She writes, “Our lost things jettison back to the places they came from.” She reflects with sparse but affecting sentimentality on the Polaroid camera left at the beach, and lines are dedicated to the grief she feels at losing a precious winter coat, gifted to her by a poet friend.

With equal weight, Smith writes of the memories she holds of her late husband, Fred “Sonic” Smith, and departed poets and artists, writing “We seek to stay present, even as the ghosts attempt to draw us away.” For the most part, M Train remains present, with a few notable drifts into vivid memories and expository dreams. Smith has a way of writing from a place of minimalism and skillfully strips away the noise that must come with being a legendary cultural figure. The sense of her fame only exposes itself in the freedom to travel that is afforded, presumably, by some measure of habit and fortune, paired with the opportunities that she’s offered.

Her experience is overwhelmingly solitary, though not lonely. The strong narrative thread that pulled the reader through Just Kids is absent in this work, and the memoir reads as if it’s not concerned with where it needs to reach. Instead it meanders from her bed, to the neighbourhood café ’ino, where she remembers her trip with Fred to a French penal colony in Saint-Laurent-du-Maroni, then off to Berlin, then London, then back to ’ino, and then off again to the memory of a day trip to Far Rockaway where she falls in love with a modest beach house months before Hurricane Sandy devastated the community. Smith travels as far as Japan and Mexico, following her whims to visit memorial sites dedicated to her long-dead muses and fulfilling her obligations as a member of the secretive Continental Drift Club.

Perhaps the most bizarre feature of the memoir is Smith’s often-discussed love of detective television shows. When she realizes her flight is delayed in London she books a few days in a local hotel to stay in and watch a BBC marathon. Smith uses detective television, particular geographic locales and Haruki Murakami’s novel The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle as narrative anchors, circling back to these topics throughout the work. M Train is skillfully crafted and carefully considered, and those who enjoyed Just Kids for its calculated account of the past will similarly enjoy Smith’s depiction of the present; however, where Just Kids saw Smith interacting with her heroes and loves, in M Train she is largely alone and removed from modern society.

––Karyn Haag

Patti Smith’s M TRAIN

Claire Vaye Watkins’ GOLD FAME CITRUS

Gold Fame Citrus, the title of Claire Vaye Watkins’ debut novel, serves as a contrast early on in the book when it becomes clear that the California Watkins writes about is different both from the fields of citrus farms promised to the Oklahoma migrants from Steinbeck’s Grapes of Wrath, and from the same Hollywood promised to the legions of casting hopefuls searching for fame and fortune. Instead, the book opens to the stark reality of a California wasteland ­– ten million dry swimming pools – and in a starlet’s abandoned mansion in the now Laureless Canyon we discover that the novel’s protagonist, Luz, has just punted a prairie dog into the library. She’s panicking.

In her 2012 collection of short stories, Battleborn, Watkins skillfully wove the landscape of an arid Nevada as an omnipresent character throughout the collection. In Gold Fame Citrus, it’s initially clear that a generations-long drought has rendered the California landscape a salty and parched wasteland. Already loaded with connotations of underhanded characters – narcissistic Hollywood heroes, gamblers, Great Depression migrants, infamous cult leaders, and serial killers – Watkins’ book is of a California many decades past this familiar scene, where inhabitants have either fled for greener parts of the United Sates or dug in against the eviction to form cult-like societies in worship of the Amargosa Dune Sea that every day threatens to crush them.

Into this setting Watkins places Luz (light in Spanish), who spent her childhood as the face of a national PR campaign for the effects of generational drought on those born at the beginning of the change. Now, long after media influence could possibly help, Luz and her boyfriend Ray must move on from the relative safety of the starlet’s mansion when they abscond with a toddler they name Estrella. Luz happens upon a migrant utopia evoking other well-known groups, and it’s here that the reader can most sense Watkins’ own history – her father a former member of the Manson family – as she carefully crafts an all-too familiar cult. This cult follows the dune sea, described as both the devil and a god, that creeps over the landscape crushing cities and leaving mutated creatures behind. In many cases, Watkins has created her own post-tragedy dictionary where new words rest on the familiarity of their origins. Gold Fame Citrus is littered with well-planned symbolism and intentionally heavy-handed allusions, and it’s clear that Watkins’ craft is deliberate.

Watkins struggles with plot in this novel, and there is little, if any, feeling of hope in the work. Maintaining an interest in the characters is difficult at times, especially when Watkins writes an entire chapter where every sentence begins with the same phrase. What could have read as an important quest or personal revelation falls flat in exchange for beautifully crafted descriptions of landscape and detailed explanations of the minute workings of post-drought communities. This work will find a place alongside other notable apocalyptic fictions such as Edan Lepucki’s California, and Emily St. John Mandel’s Station Eleven, and Watkins brings a unique and fascinating landscape that reflects just enough of the contemporary news clips to evoke a sense of haunting and urgent panic.

–– Karyn Haag

51lHwpzMZeL._SX329_BO1,204,203,200_

Claire Vaye Watkins’ GOLD FAME CITRUS

Ta-Nehisi Coates’ BETWEEN THE WORLD AND ME

The release of Ta-Nehisi Coates’ Between the World and Me comes mere weeks after the Charleston, NC shootings, and the many press appearances that Coates makes are bookended by the continued violence against Black people in the United States. The timing of this book couldn’t be more appropriate, but in the tradition of critiques on race relations, the timing would have been astute and relevant at any point in the previous decades. Deliberately crafted as a letter to his teenage son Samori – “Here is what I would like for you to know: In America, it is traditional to destroy the black body—it is heritage” and “This is your country, this is your world, this is your body, and you must find some way to live within the all of it” – Coates underlines the state of racial tension, the structural racism that permits the acts of violence against Black bodies, and the history that prescribes the current crisis in the United States.

Coates is a renowned cultural critic and intellectual noted as the thoughtful poet to James Baldwin’s angry preacher, while a blurb by Toni Morrison proclaims Between the World and Me to be required reading. Coates displays his knowledge of racial struggle as he peppers the text with quotations from his predecessors in the battle for Black freedom in the United States, making pointed reference to those in opposition. He deliberately represents himself as a Black Nationalist, and this is visible in the intellectual power of the text. Yet what makes this book resonate is represented not only in this cultural and historical grounding, but also in the initial striking moment when Coates reflects on how the death of his classmate at Howard University drew attention to the racist structures present in his country. He reflects too on his 15-year-old son’s realization of the same racism present in the grand jury’s decision to not indict the killers of Michael Brown in Ferguson. The facts are deeply personal to Coates and his son, and should be as well to many of his readers, and by humanizing the aftermath of the violence, Coates encourages the reader to empathize particularly with his son Samori. Coates personalizes the terror as he writes to his son: “And you know now, if you did not before, that the police departments of your country have been endowed with the authority to destroy your body.”

He continues in the following pages to discuss the nuances of terror one experiences while living in a Black body, recalling the anxieties of growing up in Baltimore: “Not being violent enough could cost me my body. Being too violent could cost me my body. We could not get out” and describes how he came to understand his position on the streets and in school: “I came to see the streets and the schools as arms of the same beast… Fail in the streets and the crews would catch you slipping and take your body. Fail in the schools and you would be suspended and sent back to those same streets where they would take your body.” Coates’ anxiety is palpable and he writes clearly about the deliberately frustrating binaries that Black Americans must negotiate.

Memorably, Coates explores what it means to be parented with the belief that it’s better for a parent to beat their child than have them beaten by police, and he beautifully and heartbreakingly details the fear intrinsic to parenting a Black child. “Black people love their children with a kind of obsession, you are all we have, and you come to us endangered. I think we would like to kill you ourselves before seeing you killed by the streets that America made.” Between the World and Me is deliberately painful and rests on the assertion that all violence done to Black bodies is a direct result of white supremacy.

Coates’ letter to his son begins with the state of race relations in America but continues from there as a life story, moralizing when necessary, but not hiding his son from the truth and hopelessness that he feels occupying a Black body. The result is a moving call to action – but he leaves the next step towards progress unclear. Access to community and resources is important as Coates discovered a new meaning in the Black intellectual and academic community at Howard University, and value is evident in the freedom he felt as he experienced diversity within this community. He also touches on what he refers to as the Dream, which is to say, how white people avoid confronting the race issues affecting the United States by taking comfort in the values of white America. “And for so long I have wanted to escape into the Dream, to fold my country over my head like a blanket. But this has never been an option because the Dream rests on our backs, the bedding made from our bodies.”

Critiques of the book have noted that Coates rarely acknowledges the effects of structural racism and violence on Black women in Between the World and Me, and while he discusses rape frequently in the book, he never directly addresses the women who primarily suffer these sexual assaults. With the exception of Coates’ wife, both women and any discussion of how gender affects violence are notably absent from the book, but Coates’ focus on masculinity in this text makes sense given the context of a father writing to his son about race-based violence. Given the personal nature of the writing, and delivered specifically for one Black teenage boy, the value of this book extends well beyond Samori’s demographic and is an important read for anyone grappling with how racism appears in our society.

— Karyn Haag

51ViHdI1ZtL._SX327_BO1,204,203,200_

Ta-Nehisi Coates’ BETWEEN THE WORLD AND ME