In the mid-1970s, Jan Steele worked on the front lines as a counsellor at the Calgary Women’s Emergency Shelter. Jawbreaker: Memoir of a Women’s Shelter is her account of the two and a half years she spent opening the door to women and children facing homelessness due to domestic violence, poverty, and mental illness. In the 70s, the idea that a woman could leave her abusive husband was novel, and the shelter was just getting started. The shelter was located in a three-storey Victorian home that in its heyday would have been quite fancy, but by the time Jan showed up it had become a fire hazard. At times all that stood between a belligerent abuser and his wife was a broken deadbolt that required a screwdriver to operate and the highest security was a baseball bat. Jan was optimistic about her ability to help in the shelter but she quickly transformed from a positive, fresh-faced newcomer to a seasoned regular struggling with balancing the needs of the women and the dysfunctional management.
Jawbreaker is based on a diary that Jan wrote during her time at the shelter. It reflects her self-described immaturity and depicts an incredibly blunt and heartbreaking portrait of domestic violence. Jan portrays herself as she was when she was at the shelter, and has not adapted her perspective or judgements, so at times they seem harsh or juvenile. Nothing is sugar coated, and everything is outrageously unfair. One client emigrated to Canada with her husband who was abusive and to punish her, he threw boiling oil at her face. She spent many weeks at the shelter with her head wrapped entirely in bandages before Jan ever sees the depth of the abuse she suffered. The book is a litany of similar stories. One woman seeks refuge with her four boys, but they are kidnapped by their father, and it ends with the police luring the man to the shelter, coaxing the children back, and then they serve him a ticket for illegal possession of firearms. But some stories are not so clear cut, perhaps the most troubling is that of a woman who left her dog when she fled her home. When she retuned, her husband told her he had shot the dog. She was heart broken, but then later, he told her he set the dog free. She desperately searched, but then, he told her again, the dog was dead, and on and on, the woman never learned the truth. Successes are few and fleeting, humour is scarce.
Domestic violence is still a prevalent problem, and while legal and social reforms have occurred since 1970, the assistance available to women is insufficient. The shelter could have 100 women and children a month, but more than often they had to turn women away. Resources were sparing, and the shelter could always use more of everything, and management constantly got in the way of the front-line workers, an all-too familiar story for anyone on the front lines today. Additionally, from the women Jan speaks of, it’s clear that domestic violence doesn’t affect any specific demographic, but is indiscriminate, pervading culture, class and race.
This book is startling, exhausting and frustrating, but at its core, it pays respect to the women who passed through the shelter doors, and honours the experiences of women who are victims of domestic violence. Readers interested or involved in social work, psychology and counselling will find value in the stories represented in the memoir. Jan deliberately maintains the language she used in her initial documentation that may have been common in 1970, but now feels dated and inappropriate. Some readers may find this book upsetting, as it does directly portray domestic violence and episodes of crisis, and suicide.
–Karyn Haag


